"Why raise them to die so young?": The Aesthetics of Fatalism in <i>The Tall Man</i>

Authors

  • Jane Stenning University of Notre Dame University

Keywords:

Chloe Hooper, literary journalism, creative non-fiction, The Tall Man, fatalism, victim, Palm Island, colonialism, frontier violence, dispossession

Abstract

Chloe Hooper’s The Tall Man (2008) covers the circumstances surrounding the death in custody of Palm Island man Moordinyi. It has been praised for avoiding the codes of reporting that frame Indigenous Australians negatively, such as violent threats to the social order. In the mode of book-length literary journalism, Hooper places the events surrounding Moordinyi’s death within a broader context of dispossession and colonial violence. A stated aim of literary journalism is to engage ‘Other subjectivities’ in order to achieve a deeper understanding of perspective that cannot be accommodated in the typical news cycle. If this is so, it is important to identify how the indigenous subject position has been constituted in this text. Using tools of framing analysis, this paper will illustrate how another typical and negative frame organises the text. The Tall Man deploys a ‘fatalist’ frame which tends to position indigenous people as ill-destined victims. Given the text’s ‘literary’ credentials, which carry with them a degree of cultural authority, it is important to consciously draw out these elements which reinforce a sense of hopelessness, and which tend to mirror the kinds of unequal social relations which the text itself sets out to challenge.

Author Biography

Jane Stenning, University of Notre Dame University

Lecturer, Australian Literature and Politics
School of Arts and Sciences

Downloads

Issue

Section

Articles