Citizen participation and place-making in the process of ger area redevelopment in Ulaanbaatar
Keywords:
ger area, urban planning, place-making, redevelopment, MongoliaAbstract
This article examines the relationship between citizen participation and place-making in the process of ger area redevelopment in Ulaanbaatar. Although Mongolian legislation mandates public participation in redevelopment projects, in practice the process remains predominantly expert-driven and top-down in nature. This gap between formal planning and the everyday spatial needs and experience of residents result in a disconnect between policy and lived reality. Guided by the theoretical framework of Henri Lefebvre’s Right to the City and David Sim’s Soft City concept, this study used a mixed-method approach, combining quantitative and qualitative methods of data collection in two redeveloped cases in Ulaanbaatar. Findings indicated that current redevelopment plans often fail to reflect residents’ everyday needs, social relationships, and expectations for public space. Rather than enjoying their living in apartment blocks, residents emphasized the importance of safety, comfort, and inclusivity in living environment. This article concludes that citizen participation must move beyond formal compliance and be integrated meaningfully into the place-making process, recognizing residents as co-creators of urban space.
References
Central Asian Survey, 35(2), 145-156. https://doi.org/10.1080/02634937.2016.1155862
Holman, N. (2020). No place for place-making: The impacts of permitted development rights on place-making and community wellbeing. London School of Economics & TCPA. https://nationwidefoundation.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/HHA_PDRs_hyp.pdf
Hunt, B. (n.d.). We are good at putting up buildings but we are bad at making places. Retrieved from https://rsd2-alert-durden-connections.weebly.com/placemaking.html
Lefebvre, H. (1996). The Right to the City. In Writings on Cities (Ch. 2–17). London: Blackwell. Retrieved from The Anarchist Library. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/henri-lefebvre-right-to-the-city
Legal Info (2025a). Law on Urban Development Mongolia-2018. Retrieved on 01 August, 2025 from https://legalinfo.mn/en/edtl/16532709880941
Legal Info (2025b). Law on the Redevelopment of Cities and Settlements-2015. Retreived on 01 August, 2025 from https://legalinfo.mn/mn/detail/11219
Manduul, N. (2024). The number of households living in ger areas has decreased by 6.2%. News.mn. https://news.mn/r/2749930/
Ministry of Construction and Urban Development. (2018). Research on Urban Planning and Land National Legal Institute of Mongolia. (2022). Restoration of violated rights. https://nli.gov.mn/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/17-zorchigdsn-erh-sergeeh.pdf
National Statistics Office of Mongolia. (2023). Number of households living in ger districts [Table in Mongolian].
NEWS.MN. (2024). Гэр хороололд амьдардаг өрхийн тоо 6.2 хувиар буурчээ [Ger khoroolol households decreased by 6.2 per cent]. Retrieved from https://news.mn/r/2749930/
National Legal Institute of Mongolia. (2022). Restoration of Violated Rights. Retrieved from https://nli.gov.mn/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/17-zorchigdsn-erh-sergeeh.pdf
National Statistics Office of Mongolia. (2023) Retrieved from https://www2.1212.mn/tables.aspx?tbl_id=DT_NSO_0300_027V1&RESIDENT_select_all
Pantic, V. (2023, August 22). What is placemaking and what are examples of it? Go Vocal. https://www.govocal.com/blog/5-examples-of-placemaking-in-community-engagement
Sanghera, B., Satybaldieva, E., Rodionov, A., Serikzhanova, S., Choibekov, N., & Sultanmuratova, K. (2012). Illegal settlements and city registration in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: Implications for legal empowerment, politics, and ethnic tensions. Open Society Foundations occasional paper series No. 5. NY: Open Society Foundations.
Sim, D. (2019). Soft city: Building density for everyday life. Island Press.
Shröder, P. (2016). Urban spaces and lifestyles in Central Asia and beyond: An Introduction. Sutriadi, R. (2023). Soft infrastructure in smart sustainable cities: A Literature review. The Journal of Indonesia Sustainable Development Planning. 4(2), 195-215. https://doi.org/10.46456/jisdep.v4i2.428
Ulaanbaatar City Statistical Office. (2012). One day in Ulaanbaatar 2012 [In Mongolian]. http://ubstat.mn/News=ad21aa57-435d-11e2-a37f-001fc60e81da
Ulaanbaatar City Municipality. (2020). Manual for Rural to Urban Migrants in Ulaanbaatar. Ulaanbaatar: City Municipality.
Terbish, B., Lietaert, I., Tegshee, B., Benoot, T & Roets, G. (2024). Survival strategies at the edge of the capital city of Mongolia, Ulaanbaatar: Revealing ger residents’ capacity to aspire, Journal of Urban Affairs, DOI 10.1080/07352166.2024.2302472